Iraq Body Count, 26 October 2004.
Today the Iraq Body Count (IBC) website has published its analysis of the
civilian dealth toll in the April 2004 siege of Falluja. This analysis leads
to the conclusion that between 572 and 616 of the approximately 800 reported
deaths were of civilians, with over 300 of these being women and children.
A Falluja Archive carrying relevant and related excerpts from nearly three
hundred contemporary news reports is also being made available on the
website, and constitutes the largest publicly-available resource for
investigators researching the human consequences of the siege. IBC's number
for the civilian dead emerges from detailed and exhaustive analysis of these
reports as well as others more recently published.
Press spokesman, John Sloboda said "Data recently released to the public by
the Iraqi Health Ministry has allowed IBC to resolve a problem we have been
struggling with for months: how to reconcile casualty figures reported by
local doctors of 800 total dead with a much lower estimate (280 dead)
produced in short order by the Iraqi Health Ministry (IHM), soon after US
Gen. Mark Kimmitt told the press that the CPA would ask the Ministry to 'get
a fair, honest and credible' figure. Details of our analysis are provided on
the website, but it now appears incontrovertible that the IHM estimate was
quietly withdrawn once media attention moved away from Falluja, leading us
to conclude that their estimate was acknowledged to be flawed".
The IBC totals are based on multiply-cited reports from doctors and
eyewitnesses that no less than 308 of those killed were women and children.
This number demonstrates the huge impact of US attacks on civilian areas,
and allows the conclusion to be drawn that many of the males killed must
also have been non-combatants.
There are clear reports of 600 people killed in total up until April 12th,
most of them killed before US forces began to permit women and children to
be evacuated from the town. Civilian totals have been derived by assuming a
conservative ratio of one civilian adult male killed for every woman killed
prior to April 12th, and by using the minimum-maximum range to account for
differing possible numbers of women and children remaining in the targeted
areas after the exodus had begun.
The project's Principal Researcher, Hamit Dardagan, commented "The unique
IBC Falluja Archive allows members of the public to examine for themselves
the multiple violations which yielded this shocking toll. These include
attacks on ambulances and sniper fire at children as well as the aerial
bombardment of residential areas. Talk of "precision strikes" is mere
techno-babble when these are part of military campaigns causing thousands of
civilian deaths and injuries.
"The failed US attempt to "pacify" Falluja via "overwhelming" military means
was first and foremost a disaster for its civilian population. The fact that
it also embarrassed those who ordered it is of little sigificance in
comparison, except in one regard. Current US plans to launch a "final
assault" on Falluja, supported by back filling from UK troops, suggest that
we can expect another human catastrophe whose scale no one can judge in
advance but which will certainly result in the destruction of innocent
lives. The question planners in Washington, London and Baghdad - and the
public at large - need to consider is this: are the next attacks being
planned as a true measure of last resort? If not, it is not just mass
slaughter that is being contemplated here, but mass murder."
Citation: "No Longer Unknowable: Fallujah's April Civilian Toll is 600," Iraq Body Count, 26 October 2004.
Original URL: http://electroniciraq.net/news/1684.shtml